Skip to content

Catering Menu

Catering Menu

Our Seafood is Shore to Please

Fish Tales offers a wide selection of freshly-prepared seafood options for gatherings and events from small to large. So whether you’re looking for a hot lunch, a bowl of chowder, or a delicious and easy dinner, our prepared foods are sure to please. We also serve a variety of sweet and savory sauces, marinades, spice rubs, and dips to complement your favorite fish perfectly. We cater to both small and large “groupers!”

Enjoy our homemade hot food items, made fresh to the order!

View Our Menu
Gourmet Smoked Fish Platter
Gourmet Smoked Fish Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Custom Shrimp & Jonah Cktl. Platter
Custom Shrimp & Jonah Cktl. Platter
Poached Salmon Platter
Poached Salmon Platter
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat & Snow Crab Cktl Claw Platter
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat & Snow Crab Cktl Claw Platter
Shrimp Cocktail Platter
Shrimp Cocktail Platter
Poached Salmon Platter
Poached Salmon Platter
Lobster Meat Platter
Lobster Meat Platter
Large shrimp cocktail platter with sauce, by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market
Shrimp Cocktail Platter
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat, Snow Crab Cocktail Claw & Jonah Cocktail Claw Platter
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat, Snow Crab Cocktail Claw & Jonah Cocktail Claw Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat and Lobster Meat Platter
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat and Lobster Meat Platter
Gourmet Smoked Fish Platter
Gourmet Smoked Fish Platter
Custom Shrimp & Jonah Cktl. Platter
Custom Shrimp & Jonah Cktl. Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Custom Shrimp & Jonah Cktl. Platter
Custom Shrimp & Jonah Cktl. Platter
Jumbo lump crab platter by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market
Custom Jumbo Crabmeat & Snow Crab Cktl Claw Platter
Poached Salmon Platter
Poached Salmon Platter
Shrimp Cocktail Platter
Shrimp Cocktail Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Smoked Salmon Platter
Shrimp Cocktail Platter
Shrimp Cocktail Platter

Corporate parties are welcomed. Call (718) 246-1346 to place your order.

Catering Menu (Winter 2023)

JUMBO SHRIMP COCKTAIL PLATTER

Platters include cocktail sauce, fresh lemon slices, and horseradish

  • 2 lb Platter (approx 26-30 pcs)
    $62
  • 3 lb Platter (approx 39-45 pcs)
    $87
  • 4 lb Platter (approx 52-60 pcs)
    $112
  • 5 lb Platter (approx 65-72 pcs)
    $137

*Colossal Shrimp also available

Jumbo shrimp cocktail platter from Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market
Poached salmon platter by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market

POACHED SALMON

Perfectly-cooked salmon, placed on a bed of fresh dill and garnished with thinly-sliced green & yellow squash medallions that are overlapped to beautifully represent the scales of a fish. You get your choice of any (2) of our homemade sauces per platter.

Allow ½ lb per person.

  • Organic Whole Fish
    $35/lb
  • Organic Filets
    $35/lb
  • Wild Caught Whole Fish
    $45/lb
  • Wild Caught Filets
    $45/lb

*2 lb minimum on all platters.

LARGE SHRIMP COCKTAIL PLATTER

Platters include cocktail sauce, fresh lemon slices, and horseradish

  • 2 lb Platter (approx 44-46 pcs)
    $56
  • 3 lb Platter (approx 67-69 pcs)
    $78
  • 4 lb Platter (approx 82-92 pcs)
    $100
  • 5 lb Platter (approx 110-115 pcs)
    $122
Smoked salmon platter with hearty bread, by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market

SMOKED SALMON PLATTER

Your choice of thinly-sliced smoked salmon arranged with capers, red onion, cocktail bread & our homemade dill sauce.

  • Gaspe Nova
    $95
  • Scottish
    $95
  • Norwegian
    $95
  • Irish (Organic)
    $95
  • Gravlax
    $95

Serves 8 to 10

GOURMET SMOKED FISH PLATTER

An elegant selection includes a collection of the finest smoked sable, gaspe nova, lake sturgeon, kippered salmon & whole smoked trout. Garnished with capers, red onion, and lemon, and served with rye & pumpernickel cocktail bread.

  • Serves 10-12 people
    $190.00

JUMBO LUMP CRAB PLATTER

Sweet, plump & juicy chunks of crab meat beautifully arranged and served with cocktail sauce and lemon wedges.

  • 1 lb platter
    $65
  • 2 lb platter
    $120

JONAH COCKTAIL CRAB PLATTER

Large Jonah Claws prepared cocktail style. Garnished with lemons and cocktail sauce.

  • Market Price
    Call for Pricing
Gourmet variety smoked fish platter by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market.
Steamed lobster meat platter by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market
Lobster and shrimp platter by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market

STEAMED LOBSTER MEAT PLATTER

(Nicknamed “The Game Changer…” for a good reason!)

Enjoy the succulent indulgence of lobster without having to deal with shells, nutcrackers, stain-splattered clothes, or cut fingers!

Sweet and succulent hardshell Maine lobster, steamed to perfection. All claw and tail meat removed and left intact, beautifully arranged on a bed of dill, and garnished with fresh lemon wedges.

Gourmet lobster at its finest!

  • Market Price
    Call for Pricing

COCKTAIL CRAB CAKES

Mini-sized, Maryland-style crab cakes prepared with jumbo lump crabmeat.

Perfect for large gatherings!

  • 2 dozen minimum
    $ 30.00 per dozen

FRUTTI di MARE SALAD

This Italian-style seafood salad is made with fresh calamari, shrimp & scungilli and seasoned with extra virgin olive oil, garlic, parsley, celery & lemon. 

Always a holiday favorite!

  • $35.00 per/lb

RAW BAR SET-UP

Choose from our bountiful selection of the following delights, beautifully arranged on ice and served to your guests. Set up includes cocktail sauce, fresh lemons, hot sauce, and mignonette sauce. Don’t be “shellfish…” share with friends and family!

  • Fresh steamed lobsters (Market Price)
    Call for Pricing
  • Fresh oysters (1/2 shell) (Market Price)
    Call for Pricing
  • Littleneck clams (1/2 shell) (Market Price)
    Call for Pricing
  • Alaskan king crab legs (Market Price)
    Call for Pricing
  • Sweet jumbo shrimp cocktail (Market Price)
    Call for Pricing
  • Steamed Brazilian lobster tails (Market Price)
    Call for Pricing

Personal shuckers (if needed) $50 per hr.

Cast your net for great catering by calling (718) 246-1346 to order