Skip to content

Visit Fish Tales
Gourmet Seafood Market

Fresh Seafood Market Serving Sandwiches, Soups, Catering Options, and More!

Cobble Hill’s Most Fin-tastic Gourmet Seafood Market

Founded in November 1996, the Fish Tales’ vision has always been to offer Brooklyn the highest quality seafood and the Customer Service to match. Our mission is simply to offer the most pristine and freshest fish available, with a high-quality assortment of hand-sliced smoked fish, including Nova, Sable, Sturgeon, and the most sought-after imported and domestic caviars.

Another focal point is our healthy and tasty lunch and dinner options, such as Grilled Teriyaki Salmon, Poached Salmon, Blackened Salmon, and seafood favorites, such as Shrimp Cocktail, Maryland Style Crab Cakes, Steamed Lobsters, and Maine Lobster Rolls. With all the prepping and cooking done on-premises, you can enjoy our vast selection of Soups, Salads, Fish, and Clam Chowders.

Fish Tales commits to maintaining our status as one of the premier fish markets in all of NYC. Our passion fuels our commitment to start our day at 2 am to visit the Fulton Fish Market and personally hand-select only the freshest quality fish and seafood for our customers to savor.

Owners of Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market stand in front of their shop
Fresh grilled salmon by Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market

Check out our fresh fish selection with some of our favorite recipes

And catch what our customers are cooking up on Instagram!

Fish Tales on Instagram

From whole fish to pristine fillets! Watch us fillet today’s Halibut.

Halibut has a firm but tender texture that flakes when cooked properly. Great for baking, grilling, or pan sauté. 

#fishtales #freshfish #freshfishdaily #freshseafood #wholefish #fillet #halibut #brooklyn #cobblehill #carrollgardens #dumbo #brooklynheights
Swordfish steaks, anyone ? Swordfish is great for the grill; their meat is rich and fatty, with a mild but slightly sweet flavor. Get while you can !

#fishtales #freshfish #freshfishdaily #swordfish #dayboat #grill #grilling #seafood #brooklyn #cobblehill #carrollgardens #dumbo #brooklynheights
Elevate any occasion with our custom platters! 
Here we have fresh Lobster Meat and Shrimp Cocktail, surrounded with lemon wedges, and served with cocktail sauce on the side. Whether it’s a party, meeting, or special event, we’ve got you covered. Choose from a delicious array of options tailored to your preferences! 

*Please allow 48 hour notice for any custom platter*

#fishtales #freshfish #freshfishdaily #catering #customplatters #lobster #shrimpcocktail #brooklyn #cobblehill #brooklynheights #dumbo #carrollgardens #seafood #platter
Indulge in a seafood love affair this Valentine’s Day!Place your orders now for the freshest fish and seafood to add a touch of oceanic romance to your celebration. 

Visit us at www.fishtalesonline.com to see all of our specials! Offer only valid Saturday, February 10th - Saturday, February 17th, 2024.

Limited availability, so secure your catch today!
We are Accepting Holiday Orders!

*Please Place All Orders AT LEAST “4 DAYS” In Advance *

All orders must be placed in person, or called in at (718)246-1346.

#fishtales #freshfish #freshfishdaily #seafood #brooklyn #feastofthesevenfishes #christmas #happyholidays #cobblehill #carrollgardens #brooklynheights
Did someone say Oyster Stuffing ?

We are now accepting Thanksgiving Orders! 
To place an order, call us at (718)246-1346 or visit us in person !

*PLEASE PLACE ALL ORDERS AT LEAST “3 DAYS” IN ADVANCE*

#fishtales #freshfish #freshfishdaily  #thanksgiving  #oysters #oysterstuffing #shrimpcocktail #platter #brooklyn #cobblehill #carrollgardens #brooklynheights #poachedsalmon

Today's Specials